Categories
faith

Hagia Sophia Diaries 30

Last December it was reported that Hagia Sophia suffered even more damage. The Imperial Gate under the mosaics of Saints Constantine and Justinian was damaged last year, but in December it was discovered the gate suffered more damage. Hagia Sophia appears to suffer from the ignorance of those responsible for the Great Church’s upkeep.

President Erdogan took Hagia Sophia from the ministry of culture which did a good job preserving the Church, and gave it to the clerics who are completely indifferent to both the Christian origins of Hagia Sophia and the historical significance of the Church. The upcoming Turkish elections will be significant.

Will Hagia Sophia be restored as a museum in a post Erdogan government? This remains to be seen.

Categories
Letters

Letter To Senator

My name is Theodore Karakostas and I am a Greek Orthodox Christian. This is not a political letter, but a letter motivated by concerns over religion, democracy, and freedom of conscience. 
At the present time, the Ukrainian government is attempting to outlaw the Ukrainian Orthodox Church. This Church is one of three religious institutions claiming to be an Orthodox Church in that country. The dogmatic and ecclesiological matters are a matter of importance to Orthodox Christians and so I will not delve into this particular matter. 

The Ukrainian Orthodox Church (not to be confused with the rival Orthodox Church of Ukraine) has condemned the Russian invasion of Ukraine. Despite this, the Zelensky government is intent on outlawing the Church and has permitted angry mobs with fascist sympathies to seize Churches in order to give them to the religious institution presently favored by the Kiev government. In a democratic society, the government should not care where people choose to worship and citizens should not be discriminated against or suffer violence because of choices they make in matters of religion. 

The Ukrainian Orthodox Church has been persecuted by the Ukrainian authorities long before the Russians invaded. The Ukrainian government has targeted an entire community because of the choices they make in matters of faith. The Ukrainian Orthodox Church is being targeted because it is under the spiritual leadership of the Russian Orthodox Church. The hierarchy of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church has condemned the Russian invasion and provided support for all Ukrainians regardless of religious affiliation. 

At the present time, the Ukrainian authorities are attempting to seize the Kiev Caves Lavra (a monastic complex) of Kiev which is the holiest site in Ukraine. The government is trying to evict the monks and seminarians even though they have done nothing wrong. Angry mobs have been harassing the monks and ordinary Ukrainians who have shown up at the monastery to show their support for the monastery and the monks. There is nothing political about this, and under no circumstances does concern for the freedom of religion for the Ukrainian Orthodox Church have any sort of implications regarding the war. 

Roman Catholics throughout the world are under the spiritual authority of the Papacy. This does not make Roman Catholics loyal to the Italian government. As a Greek Orthodox, I am under thespiritual authority of the Patriarch of Constantinople from Turkey, and I have no sympathies for the Turkish government. The Ukrainian government is violating the right to religious freedom for millions of Ukrainians. American taxpayers are subsidizing the government of Ukraine.

The American government must demand that the government in Kiev cease and desist from interfering in the religious lives of its citizens. The Ukrainian Orthodox Church must be granted the same rights and recognitions that other religious institutions in Ukraine enjoy. 

Theodore Karakostas
Milton

Categories
Published Letters

Greek Churches Must Speak

LETTER TO EDITOR

Letter to the Editor: On the Orthodox Church in Ukraine

April 5, 2023

The National Herald

twitter

(Photo: TNH, File)

(Photo: TNH, File)

To the Editor:

The Greek-speaking world has always prided itself on its devotion to the faith of Christ and the Orthodox Church. As such, it is of extreme importance that we must raise our voices to condemn the barbaric persecution of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church and its most important shrine, that of the Kiev Caves Lavra. From the strict point of view of canon law and Orthodox ecclesiology the Ukrainian Orthodox synod of Metropolitan Onuphry is the canonical Church of Ukraine. There is a schismatic entity called ‘Orthodox Church of Ukraine’ which lacks canonicity, catholicity, and apostolicity. Its creation is in fact highly irregular and problematic and threatens to destroy Orthodox unity.

From a democratic standpoint, religious freedom and freedom of conscience are extremely important. This means that each individual has the right to follow whatever religion or faith that they like. In Greece for example, individuals may worship within the canonical Church of Greece, or they may worship among the old calendar churches. Or they may attend Roman Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, or Muslim services. The point is they have the right to worship as they like.

The Ukrainian government has effectively decided to outlaw the Ukrainian Orthodox Church. These are outright fascist policies that target an entire group of people because they worship within the Ukrainian Orthodox Church which was always recognized by all Orthodox Churches (including Constantinople) as the canonical Church of Ukraine until 2018. The decision of individuals to worship within the Ukrainian Orthodox Church is a basic human right supported by the right to religious freedom and freedom of conscience.

The Ukrainian government has been seeking to evict over two hundred monks from the Kiev Caves Lavra, the holiest site in Ukraine. Kiev reasons that because the Ukrainian Orthodox Church is under the omophorion of the Patriarchate of Moscow there must be some sort of sinister political designs at work. This is like saying that Greek Orthodox in America and those parts of Greece (Crete, the Dodecanese islands, Mount Athos) that are under the Ecumenical Patriarchate must have some secret loyalty to the Turkish government.

Were Roman Catholics around the world disloyal to their own countries when Mussolini was in power, or when Rome was under Nazi occupation? We should remember that the Turkish government has in the past accused the Ecumenical Patriarchate of having political designs and has bestowed a policy of repression upon it.

The Greek speaking Orthodox churches must find their voices and must condemn the oppression of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church. The Greek Churches should remember the bravery of martyred Patriarch-Saint Gregory V, Metropolitan Chrysostom of Smyrna, Archbishop Damaskinos of Athens, and the late and beloved Archbishop Christodoulos who always spoke out against injustice.

Theodore Karakostas

Boston, MA

Categories
political

Madonna, Biden, And The Trans Evil

This past week six people (three of them children) were murdered in a school shooting perpetrated by a “trans” woman. The school was an Evangelical Christian school. The murderer was a former student who reportedly harbored resentment at her Evangelical family’s opposition to transgenderism.

The murders were anti Christian. This has been ignored by the media which continues to espouse the deranged cause of trans psychopaths. Madonna has announced she will perform at a benefit concert for the trans community. Not for the families of the people who were murdered.

Madonna seeks to oppose a law in Tennessee that prohibits drag queens from performing in public places where children are present. Madonna has denounced laws in general that seek to keep LGBT sexual ideology away from children. Madonna recently did a photo shoot with Vanity Fair in which she blasphemously dressed as both Jesus Christ and the Mother of God.

Reasonable people recognize that parents have a right to raise children according to their values. The LGBT activists demonstrate that their entire cause is without reason, logic, or morality. They have demanded and received access to other people’s children in schools and public libraries. They recognize no limits which is demonstrated by their efforts to indoctrinate children.

School libraries include books on homosexuality and transgenderism. Public libraries host shows by drag queens with sexual overtones which are attended by children. The massacre in Nashville was for years preceded by an organized effort from the trans activists to indoctrinate children.

Dylan Mulvaney is a YouTube “performer” who “discovered” he is a woman. He was able to visit the White House and interview Joe Biden. He asked Biden about the legislation passed by Republicans across the country which prohibit transitioning (sex changes) for minors. Joe Biden referred to such legislation as “immoral”.

That says something about Biden and the Democratic Party. In the aftermath of the massacre, attention is given to lunatic trans activists rather than the victims. Madonna, Biden and others who refuse to stop the trans evil are morally complicit in child abuse.

It also indicates the rising threat to all Christians in America and the west.

Categories
Commentary

The Ecumenical Patriarchate And The Great Lavra

As of this writing, it appears the faithful Ukrainian monks of the Great Lavra are going to be forcibly evicted by the fascist police. Orthodox hierarchs worldwide are holding all night vigils and contacting their elected officials to intervene. In America, Metropolitan Tikhon of Orthodox Church in America (OCA) has raised his voice with Orthodox hierarchs.

Archbishop Elpidophoros of the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese has said nothing. The morally and spiritually bankrupt Archdiocese has nothing to say on the matter. The Archbishop who marched with the Marxist “black lives matter” and held a liturgy in that pagan temple used by the anti Christian Episcopalians is silent to the plight of the monks of the Great Lavra.

Patriarch Bartholomew has demonstrated he cares only about power. In 2018, he colluded with the State Department to carve up the Russian Orthodox Church. He granted “autocephaly” to a depraved group of laymen who were either defrocked by the Russian Church or never ordained by the real Church.

Patraiarch Bartholomew had no authority to intervene in Ukraine. From 1992 (the origin of the Ukrainian schism) until 2018, the Patriarchate’s official position was that the synod under Moscow was the legitimate Church in Ukraine. It has always been evident that the Patriarch changed his stance because of political factors.

The Churches of Greece, Cyprus, and Alexandria blindly followed Constantinople’s suicidal path. The Greeks of 1821 and 1940 would be appalled by the slavish manner with which today’s Greek hierarchs obeyed the State Department. On matters of faith and ecclesiology.

We have forgotten the State Department’s apathy toward the Greeks of Constantinople and the ethnic cleansing process by the Turks since 1955. The collusion between the Greek hierarchs of Constantinople and the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese with the State Department is obscene. Never let it be forgotten that the Russian Orthodox Church in 1955 condemned the anti Greek pogroms by Turkey.

I’m 2004, Russia helped kill the Annan Plan for Cyprus which would have sealed the Turkish occupation. In 2010, the Russians helped open the Patriarchal Monastery of Pangia Soumela in Trebizond. Russophobia infected the Greeks.

For several years the canonical Ukrainian Church has been persecuted by President Zelensky and his predecessor Petro Poroshenko. This started long before the war. The Ukrainian government and its Neo Nazi militias accuse the legitimate Ukrainian Church of being pawns for Moscow.

The hypocrisy is astounding. The synod of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church has in fact condemned the Russian invasion. This means nothing to the fascists who lead Zelensky by the nose. The fascists who have been seizing Churches over the last several years have taken them for political reasons.

The blasphemers in Zelensky’s government intend to use the relics of Saints in the Great Lavra to attract visitors to the museum that the Monastery is going to become.

The Ukrainian bishops are accused of serving Russia. This is interesting considering the degree to which the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Greek Orthodox Archdiocese serve Turkish and American interests. In 2018, Patriarch Bartholomew blessed the Turkish Army before it invaded the Kurdish region of Syria. Archbishop Elpidophoros appeared with officials of Turkey and the leader of the Turkish occupation of Cyprus in the fall of 2021.

Which bishops are serving which governments? The Greek and Greek American media have been ominously quiet about the Ukrainian schism since it began. Deference to Patriarch Bartholomew has reached an extreme point to which Greeks are unaware that American influence has a hold over the hierarchs in all Greek speaking Churches. This is appalling.

There are voices suggesting the Ecumenical Patriarchate should be abolished. This blog is not among those voices despite abhorring and condemning all of Patriarch Bartholomew’s actions in Ukraine. The downfall of the Ecumenical Patriarchate will occur because it has deviated from Orthodox ecclesiology.

The Ecumenical Patriarchate holds a “primacy of honor” and holds first place among Orthodox Churches. That may change very soon. The Ecumenical Patriarchate turned its back on its sister Churches and Orthodox faithful everywhere to align itself with the atheistic and neo pagan establishment in Washington.

The Patriarch of the Georgian Orthodox Church has written to Patriarch Bartholomew asking him to speak out on the persecution of the Monks of the Great Lavra. The Patriarch’s refusal to speak and to repent may bring about the end of the Ecumenical Patriarchate.

Categories
Letters

Letter To National Review


Bobby Miller in his March 26 article hopes that Turkish President Erdogan will lose the elections. Unfortunately, he hopes that Kemal Kilicdaroglu will win the elections. The latter 
is the head of the Republican People’s Party which is no better than Erdogan’s Party. Both of these men are extreme Turkish nationalists and both of them openly call for invading Greece and seizing the Greek islands. Mr. Miller appears to be a throwback to the writers that believed Turkey was some kind of secular utopia before Erdogan totally destroyed that myth. 

Mr. Miller shows no concern for Greece, Cyprus, Armenia, or the Kurds who are all being victimized by the present regime in Ankara. The Erdogan regime threatens Greece and Cyprus,
and has armed the terrorist state of Azerbaijan which started a war with Armenia and carried out war crimes and ethnic cleansing against Armenian soldiers and civilians alike. Is there 
ever a time when American writers on foreign policy will give up on the myth of Turkey?

Kilicdaroglu heads the party that was founded by Mustafa Kemal and was later led by “bloody” Bulent Ecevit. Kemal was the homicidal maniac who presided over the mass extermination
of Greek, Armenian, and Assyrian Christians in Asia Minor. Ecevit ordered the bloody Turkish invasions of Cyprus in 1974. Virtually all of Turkey’s political leaders in Parliament have 
criticized Erdogan.

They have not criticized him for his authoritarianism and for his intolerance of Christians. For example, they have not criticized his conversion of the Greek Orthodox Hagia Sophia into a Mosque back in 2020. They have criticized him for not following through on his threats to invade the islands of Greece which they refer to as “occupied territory”. Turkey will remain a threat to American interests as Ankara will remain hostile to the Kurds who represent a real future for democracy in the region were they ever to gain any form of independence. 

Theodore Karakostas
Boston

Categories
faith

On the Convening Of A Council

Archbishop Anastasios of Albania has again called for the convening of a council to resolve the schism in Orthodoxy. The Archbishop had called for the convening of a council from the time the crisis in the Church began. There is however a serious risk in convening a council now.

There have been very serious developments since Patriarch Bartholomew intervened in Ukraine. Bishops in Greece and Cyprus have entered into communion with the fake entity in Ukraine. The Patriarchate of Alexandria recognized the fake entity.

The Russian Church broke communion with some bishops (including the primates) in Greece and Cyprus. It has broken off communion entirely with the Alexandrian Patriarchate. Unlike Constantinople which did not break communion with Moscow (after Moscow broke communion with Constantinople), Alexandria has broken communion with Moscow.

There is therefore a full rupture in communion between Alexandria and Moscow. This happened after the Russian Church established a presence in the territory of Africa after Alexandria refused to reverse its recognition of the fake church in Ukraine. Then there is the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

Would the convening of a council change anything for the better at this time? A council at this point might have the opposite effect of what the Archbishop hopes will happen. As long as the war in Ukraine continues, anti Russian sentiment will continue and the State Department will not relinquish its grip over the Greek speaking Churches.

The best course of action is to wait for the war to end and international tensions to ease. A council can only be effective if political interests do not intrude. During the Cold War, the Soviet Union tried to use the Russian Church for its own goals.

The US is doing likewise with the Greek Churches today. A successful council convening under the guidance of the Holy Spirit must happen. But when the time is right.

During the iconoclastic controversy, it took sixty years before the Church fathers gathered at Nicea to discern the truth. Even after that, iconoclasm made comeback and it was not until another fifty six years that the truth prevailed against the iconoclasts.

Saint Athanasius struggled against the Arian heresy for decades even after the first Ecumenical council of 325 AD. There need be no rush to convene a Council. We do not need to risk a repetition of the debacle that occurred at Crete in 2016.

Categories
political

Farewell To Patrick Buchanan

The great Patrick Buchanan retired from journalism this past January. Buchanan was a fine conservative who sought to save the Republican Party from the neoconservatives. He ran for President in 1992 and 1996.

Buchanan served in the Nixon and Reagan administrations. After the Cold War, he became an anti war conservative and his ideas were later shared by Donald Trump. Buchanan opposed the Gulf War in 1990 and denounced the neocons.

In 1992, the neocon establishment closed ranks behind the elder Bush and defeated Buchanan. At the Republican National Convention Buchanan gave a great speech referring to the religious and cultural war under way for the soul of America. Buchanan anticipated the problems America would have by intervening in other countries and the rise of the LGBT movement.

In 1996, Buchanan won the Republican primary in New Hampshire. The neocons succeeded in defeating him much as they would later work to bring down Donald Trump. In 2003, Buchanan became a founder of the American Conservative which opposed the Iraq War from the very beginning.

Buchanan proved to be correct on Iraq and the Middle East. Buchanan opposed the expansion of NATO. He was right when so many foreign policy “experts” were wrong. His voice will be missed but at least his ideas live on in Donald Trump’s candidacy for President.

Categories
books

Venizelos

Book Review

Venizelos The Making of a Greek
Statesman, 1864-1914
By

Michael Liewellyn-Smith

Oxford University Press.2021

This biography of the great Greek statesman is the first of a two volume biography by Smith. Smith is also the author of “Ionian Vision Greece in Asia Minor 1919-1922”. It is a very good and detailed read focusing heavily on the early life and subsequent rise of Venizelos from his life in Crete to his leadership of Greece during the Balkan Wars.

Venizelos was active in the movement in Crete to break from the Ottoman Empire. Union with Greece was not possible at the beginning of the struggle and Crete originally became an autonomous part of the empire. It is during this period that tensions between Venizelos and the Greek monarchy developed.

Tensions developed between Venizelos and Prince Nicholas who governed Crete. These are the roots of what would become the national schism in 1920. Interesting is the fact that relations between Venizelos and then Captain John Metaxas were good after the former became Prime Minister of Greece.

This is very good but cannot be judged until the second and final volume is completed. The book ends after the great success of Greece in the Balkan Wars. The high point of the career of Venizelos was to come later when Greece entered Smyrna.

The best biography of Venizelos hithero was written by Doris Alastos in 1942. The most politically important biography of Venizelos as it pertained to the Asia Minor campaign was written by Herbert Adam Gibbons in 1920.

This is a fine addition to the study of the life of Venizelos but is incomplete until the arrival of the final volume.

Categories
books

Putin

Book Review

Putin

By

Philip Short

Henry Holt and Company. NY. 2022

It is rare these past few years to get any objectivity on matters pertaining to Russia. Bookstores have seen many biographies on Putin hit their shelves. At a close glance, they appear propagandistic and biased.

Previous to this, only the biography “Putin the New Tsar” by Steven Lee Myers looked at the life of the Russian leader with objectivity. Now there is this new biography by Philip Short which is quite good.

Short does not like Putin and considers him a bad guy but the book reads as fact rather than commentary. The author is objective and gives Putin his due many times. The author affirms many important facts regarding Putin.

Putin came to power with the intention of aligning with the west. He was pro western after 9/11 when the Bush administration went to war in Afghanistan. Things went sour over time but a crucial factor in the deterioration of relations between Russia and the west was when the Bush-Cheney administration declared that Ukraine and Georgia would join NATO.

The book is an excellent biography that includes details of Putin’s youth and family background and his career and rise to power. It is an excellent source for researching what is happening with Russia at the present time.